Porta Potty Forum

Porta potty for a 9-month barn build: rent or buy?

Luis A.asked 0 viewsHome Renovations & Long-termBuying vs rentingLong term rentalRural placementStandard unit

My family is starting a nine-month barn build on our property outside Bozeman. We have a crew of four to six people working five days a week. There's no septic system, and the nearest portable toilet rental company is a 40-mile drive away. I'm weighing whether to rent a standard portable toilet for the duration or buy one outright and just pay for a vacuum truck to come pump it. The ground is level gravel where our driveway ends, so truck access is good. A rental would mean a long drive for the service truck every week, which I know adds to the cost. But buying a unit means I own a used portable toilet at the end. Has anyone done the math on a long project like this? Which way did you go and were you happy with the choice?

1 answer

Sorted by votes
0
Brad L.Kansas City, MO

Rent it on a long-term rental and have it serviced once a week. Buying looks cheaper until you notice the vacuum truck still has to drive those same 40 miles to pump your unit, so the trip doesn't go away. You just lose the cleaning and restocking that come with a rental service visit.

For four to six people, one standard unit covers you. OSHA 1926.51 calls for one toilet for 20 or fewer workers, so you're well inside that.

The bigger issue for you is winter. Nine months starting now outside Bozeman means that holding tank is going to freeze. Ask the rental outfit about winterization, usually a brine or antifreeze charge in the tank, and whether they keep servicing when your road gets rough. If you own the unit, keeping it from freezing solid is your problem.

We framed a pole barn over a winter and the owner had bought his own unit. He ended up scrubbing it himself every week and chasing down someone licensed to haul the waste. He told me he'd never do it again.

Park it on the gravel at the end of the driveway where the truck can back right up, stake it down against the wind, and you'll be fine.

Your answer

Log in or create a free account to answer this question.